The Best Baseball Talk Online™      About | Terms of Service | FAQ | Moderators
1 / 49
Oct 2021

Since there is a lot of debate about Harper and Wheeler, lets have a small CBC (just like old times)

  1. Does Bryce Harper win the MVP?

  2. Does Bryce Harper win the Hank Aaron award?

  3. What place does Zack Wheeler finish in the Cy Young voting?

  4. Does Ranger Suarez get at least one Cy Young vote?

  5. Does any Phillie (Jean Segura a possibility) win a gold glove?

  • created

    Oct '21
  • last reply

    Nov '21
  • 48

    replies

  • 4.2k

    views

  • 11

    users

  • 8

    likes

  • 25

    links

  1. Harper will be MVP.

  2. Vladdy gets the Hank Aaron (or is there one for each league?)

  3. Wheeler finishes third.

  4. Suarez gets three or four Cy votes.

  5. No gold glovers.

one per league

Yes
No - I think Soto gets this
3rd - Max gets the Cy Young
Yes
No

NO MVP
Yes, Arron award
3rd CY Young vote
Yes at least a vote
No GG

No MVP
No Aaron
4th in CY Young
No votes for Suarez
No GG
I guess I am feeling negative :grinning:

I didnt realize the Hank Aaron award was a fan vote.. Vote here

It is funny to me that the Hank Aaron award is the best offensive player in a league. Not that I am against any award with one of my sports heroes associated with it, but that isnt the right category for him.

He may not have ever been the best offensive player in a league. OK, maybe a couple seasons, but really that isnt what is remarkable about him.

The Hank Aaron award should be for the best player over the last 5 years. He wasnt acutely great, he was chronically great (you know what I mean :slight_smile: ). He was ultra-steady. He played year after year and was one of the best players around, you could absolutely count on him, but he wasnt going to have that crazy great year, just another very, very good one.
Additionally, it should be awarded to the guy that EVERY parent in the country hopes his kid becomes. The best person in the game. The one that will overcome anything that the media or ignorant people will throw at him and still hold his head up high and do the best he can. And not make the news for stupidity, but for class.
That should be the Hank Aaron award, that said, I will take this one as the namesake also, but I just think it is a little off of what the guy brought to the table.

14 days later

Well put.

There seems to be a bajillion awards anymore:

Beloved by Phillies fans. Respected by his peers.

Congratulations to Bryce Harper on being named the National League Outstanding Player in the 2021 Players Choice Awards! pic.twitter.com/lYf5kY3zPI1

— Philadelphia Phillies ( @Phillies ) October 28, 2021

Bryce Harper is the 2021 National League Outstanding Player, which is voted on by the players and awarded by the @MLBPA .

— Matt Breen ( @matt_breen ) October 28, 2021

10 days later

No Gold glove awards for the Phillies. Cardinals win 5 of the 9 NL GGs

No Phillies won Gold Gloves? I'm shocked, shocked.

My prediction: Harper wins the NL MVP, Wheeler finishes third in the NLCYA vote.

Harper, Tatis and Soto are the finalists for the MVP Award

Wheeler, Scherzer and Burnes are the finalists for the Cy Young