Yeah but take away McCutchen's WAR, plus consider Hoskins' reduced WAR last year, plus the assumption (at least from me) that Santana has a comfort zone in Cleveland/the AL that wouldn't have happened here.
Last year, Santana + Hoskins was 2.2 WAR total; this year Hoskins alone is already at 2.1 and will exceed that.
Plus we'd owe him $20 million next year, can he do it again?
As it turns out we needed every inning of Nicasio too, even if he's bottomed out.