Andrew Painter is now slated to join the Phillies. I certainly do not know if this is a good pick or not, but it seems to be a very reasonable pick. Best case, he turns out to be a solid starting pitcher in the majors in a few years, but we all know that there probably is an equal chance that he never really pans out. That said, I would say the same for anybody else that they might have picked.
Most pitchers come back from JT. It's shoulders that I worry about. I think Abel and Painter are both very good picks -- they are the kind of risks you need to take if you want a good pitching staff. Both clearly have the talent to be good MLB pitchers. It's now down mainly to keeping them healthy and also to development. I will take that any day in a first rounder. Too many of our first round position player first rounders have been guys whose success depended upon a lot of development going right, because they had big holes in their game. And, we've learned that our top position prospects can also wash out due to injury. The way the Phillies have drafted recently, I'm not even convinced that a H.S. RHP, although traditionally the riskiest demographic, is actually riskier than the typical Phillies first rounder.
Sorry, read to fast and butchered that. How long will JT catch. Bob Boone caught to a ripe old age.
It really all boils down to development. Especially with Abel and Painter. They do look like they have the potential to become pitchers at he MLB level. On the negative side with players such as these is that they are a long way away from the show and need an amount of refinement. On the plus side, they have not been exposed to college programs that are focused on winning at any costs in order to maintain their jobs and will abuse players in order to do that.
Hopefully the Phillies now have the instructors in place that can bring along these young arms. There is some evidence this year that that is so as a few of the top notch pitching prospects are showing growth as the year goes on.
Hitters that intrigue me at 49
College Hitters
Ethan Wilson, OF, South Alabama
Jud Fabian, OF, UFlorida
Christian Franklin, OF, UArkansas
Adrian Del Castillo, C/1B, UMiami
Alex Binelas, 1B/3B, Louisville
HS Hitters
Lonnie White, OF, HS, PA
Wes Kath, SS/3B, HS, AZ
Izaac Pacheco, SS, HS, TX
James Wood, OF, HS, FL
Tyler Whitaker, OF, HS, NV